Disagree with that, Tansey is a good one on one defender, Hall isn't.

You have been watching a different Tansey to me. Granted he started well but he is missing or falling off a lot of tackles over the last 4 or 5 games for me.

Well that's over 50 less games than what Hall has been falling off tackles in.

I am not denying Hall is awful in defence. Just for a full back Tanseys defence at times is very poor.

The thing is that it isnt just Hall defence, he drops to many balls and make the wrong decison too many times with ball in hand. He is also lazy and doesnt help the team out like Yeaman and Briscoe do.



Apart from a good try every 5 games I'm not sure what he adds to the team at the moment.

Good assessment.

Except that it's a try every two games on average so far this season.

One of Hull's worst performers this year mate. You have to be able to play to the required standard with and without the ball. Typifies the half-d attitude that loses games. Tansey is another in that mould.

I said a good try, that he created and scored himself.

so thats 1 in 14 this year then

Oh I'm not arguing that he's been poor this season - especially disappointing in the last few games. About the only thing decent is his scoring record.





Can't quite get my head around him TBH. Seemed an exciting signing but has gone downhill since being dropped. Maybe suffering the attitude problem that seems to afflict a number of our squad.

A tad subjective.