Just out of interest, why wouldnt Hull fans choose him? He was our most important attacking weapon for numerous years in the noughties and we have been suffering in attack for the last 2 seasons since he went imo.



The mud around him leaving shouldnt tarnish the fact that he was a great player for FC.



My answer would be Swain though.

Richard Swain. End of.

Overall consistency is Swain hands down but for his 1st 2 seasons with us...Jason Smith was simply superb a ball playing 13 and a pleasure to watch.



Also i thought Adam Maher was very under-rated and was a big influence in the team as well.

Similar could be said about Shayne McMenemy. One of my favourite players of all time.

Totally agree....we always looked a better unit with him in the pack.

He brought a certain amount of defensive toughness to the pitch didnt he. We looked tighter with him out there.

Shaun Briscoe





Would also consider Dowes if you want consitancy over a long period

Good call Karl......a lot of people on here should remember that....he is very consistent.

Agree about Adam Maher.My favourite player of the past decade.Work rate was outstanding and he was hard as nails as well.

For the best in terms of ability alone the two that stand out above everyone are Jason Smith followed by Judus, Richie Barnett is another one who just oozed class, and some the solo efforts that Colin Best produced put him up there as one of the most talented players to wear the shirt this decade.



Although taking everything into account the two best players for the club this decade have been Richad Swain and Richard Horne in my opinion, a mention to Prescott aswell although he played some of his best stuff for us in the 99 season aswell as 2003.

He has been consistantly average over a long period, nothing more IMO.



Swain was consistanly top class, whilst Jason Smith and Richie Barnett (snr) were both world class performers.

Jason Smith for his world class skill set.

Richard Swain for his phenomenal work rate and sheer tenacity.