If he could just cut out the silly penalties I'd agree. He gave away another dozy penalty yesterday and we can't afford them. So many tries are scored off the back of opposition mistakes or penalties that having a liability running around giving away daft penalties is not good. If he can sort that out and the price is right I'd say keep him.



A full pre-season with us and he should be a fitter animal too.

Cant blame him for penalties yesterday, Smith wasnt playing to the rules



The highlights are on the SL website, first 30s of footage shows Scully's worth admirably imo.

There was one daft one which sticks in the mind and he's done it a couple of times now, when he holds the man down onto him. He does it when he's tackling and when he's got the ball too.



I didn't think Smith was much crack yesterday either, FWIW. Wigan went to sleep after every tackle.

Aye, that holding the tackler on to you must be a Wigan thing, saw their players do it a lot on sunday.

Thought Scully had a belter yesterday and is looking trimmer already. Superb quick flick out for Leroy to score in the corner.

He has some skills, no mistake.