I've yet to be convinced by Chapman, St Claire still looks like too much of an act for him to follow. Thought Sunday's coverage was an improvement on Saturday's - French and Davies were terrible, would have been better off with French and Saunders!

Perhaps if Lee Briers had been playing during this period, rather than Briars, Warringtion may have won!



I agree with most of whats been said before, though I think the only issue with the coverage was there was no Clare Balding. (And yes, I do realise the reason for it.)

I can cope with a creative pronunciation or two - much better than Hinge & Bracket arguing amongst themselves and dissecting every decision the ref makes in an attempt to create controversy.

I don't understand why they persist with RHP, he hasn't improved one bit in recent years so just get rid. He spoils an otherwise decent and professional team.

Yes but he appears to one of the "inner circle" along with Millward and Noble. One reason for me why Superleague Show is such a turnoff. Lets get rid of them and just keep Tanya!!

Boots 'N' all isn't exactly the Footy show, another awful Sky presentation.

That does seem to be something of an issue with both broadcasters; I don't know anything about how TV works, but there does seem to be reluctance to change faces, unless they're involved in some kind of sex scandal of course.

Sky is infinitely better for mine, I guess it is just a matter of personal preference.

Sky's production values are higher, although they focus too much on trying to create controversy and scrutinising the performance of the officials.



The BBC, when they use Woods and either Kear or Noble, edge it in commentary. Sky have become formulaic and predictable, with Stevo just trotting out the same random phrases like John Motson on an old version of FIFA.

I agree with the comments about the BBC team. Long may it continue



I disagree with the (early page) comments about Sky. They are just different. Wells, McDermott and Carney I like a lot. Clarke I like but he needs a different role.

Stevo I think is coming to the end of his time but I'm ok with Eddie. I think we could just do with some variety in his role.

Rod Studd I can't decide.

PROBLEM WITH SKY IS EVERYONE SHOUTING ALL THE TIME!!!