that french bloke should be downgraded to the junior girls netball team...what a tosspot.

Quite whistle happy but who cares!!!

Was,,,Tierry Alibert....and we got the performance what was expected.....poop!!!!!!!!!!

We had Ganson last night and he is a cheat which we expect anyway, but Allibert is totally incompetent

However, we really didn't help ourselves. With one or two totally mysterious decisions, we pretty much deserved what we got. In fact, a few of our forward passes were missed.



Thankfully, though, there was a kindly touch judge who saved our buttocks twice. I do think Halibut needs some help, as clearly Mr Ganson did on one occasion this evening also.

what did the penalty count finish?...something like 15 to 6 in the wire's favour.

did we get a penaty in the 2cnd half?

The main thing everybody ( Mr. Cummins please note ) everybody has learnt from that match is that French clown should never referee an important game again.

The French ref for the Halifax - Widnes game the other night was far better than Halibut. I don't mind us conceding penalties but when the other teams' go unpunished for the same offence it stinks.

he got the majority of decisions right but bottled out on the big one.



He obviously thought Saints were offside for the Foster try, and they were. It should have been a penalty to Wire, however under the current rules it needs to change.



We should look at the last play the ball, in it's entirety. You all know how much I have argued about incorrect play the balls in the past.

However if we do it we need the funding for video technology at all games as in the NRL.

It's not the ones he gave but the ones he didn't give that is annoying. No way were we 15 - 6 worse than wire tonight.

agree with rogues the play the ball should count and foster try shouldnt of been a try but hay im a saints fan and so what im happy with the result, i bet westwood wont be to happy

Look I was completely neutral tonight. A Saints win helped us, but that was a match changing decision and it was wrong ( but correct under the current regime)



The thing is I'm arguing something that I've been arguing for ages, so don't accuse me of trolling.