Never believe anything typed entirely in caps lock.

Another delusional clown who's had too many jamaican roll ups!



Warrington fans thought the same last year but at least they had a decent coach/squad and a chance of success you are just living in cloud cuckoo land.

In all fairness Salford have, IMO, done the best recruitment for next season so far. However i stand with you on the fact that it is highly unlikely Sinfield will be added to that list.

In terms of improving what they had then yeah fair enough but they are way off the top 6 still and the best recruiting thus far in terms of quality is by Saints and Wigan by plenty.

True, they still need a lot more to be contenders. We have recruited quality but we only have 3 players in (4 if you include the young 18 y.o winger) and around 6 or 7 out. I think if we don't make anymore signings in the backs we may struggle next year for coverage.



And I must say I overlooked Wigan, you make a fair point there.

I'll be interested to see how many English qualified Salford end up with.



They appear to have hoovered up a lot of decidedly average antipodeans since the end of the season. Palea'aesina, Bailey, Anderson (V), Nero and Leo-Latu are all purely journeymen standard these days and an indictment on the British game's ability to produce the quality required ...... unfortunately.



Luke Patten is the exception amongst their 'overaseas' recruits but only time will tell if he's 100% committed in what will be akin to him joining a 'championship club' set-up.

A: These English, Scottish, Welsh or Irish players will be with us:

Ratchford, Gibson, Broughton, McGilivray, Smith, Sneyd, Spencer, Sidlow, Jewitt, Boyle, Wild, Adamson, Neal, Parker and others.

B: To date we've chosen not to hoover up any of your antipodean journeymen

but there's still time



C: Yes, Luke Patten appears to be the best signing we have made so far, but If he proves to be as committed as Daniel Holdsworth (and just as effective), I'll be more than happy.

D: The 'Championship Club' set up, as you so put, will be for just one more season. And whilst the new stadium at Barton will not be anywhere near full (unless of course Leeds, Wigan, Saints, Hull and Wire bring a hell of a lot more fans than they did this year), it'll certainly be more akin to SL standard than a few others.

I don't expect Kevin Sinfield to join Salford. I'd love him to as he's been one of the best SL players year in year out for the last few years. But let's face it, he's just not going to is he.

I've tried to answer without any bitterness, but it does seem that very few fans of other clubs have much respect or enthusiasm for what our board is trying to achieve, and the criticism that goes with it seems a bit petty imo.

Has Ratchford signed a new deal then Jim?

Good for the club if he has but he needs to be playing at 6 imo and Holdsworth at 13.

He has, I'm not sure if it's a 2 or 3 year deal.

I think he's going to find himself as a utility player as Holdsworth will defo be at 6 and Patten certain to secure the number 1 shirt.

All a bit weird really, as we all rate him very highly, and even last year in a poor(ish) team he couldn't secure a regular spot. Injuries had him sidelined once or twice which didn't help.

He has a bit of the maverick about him, which we've not had for a long time, but I just think McRae doesn't rate him as much as the fans do. I could be wrong.

I do think he could find a regular place in other SL teams and would hate to lose him.

What would you have done with the Baldwin's?

That's a little harsh. Although, I would say we could have, prehaps, signed some younger players.



Anderson is a very good player, Danny Tickle knows all about how hard he tackles. Palea'asina still avergaes over 8 metres per carry, and a change of team may bring him back to his wrecking ball best? The little I've seen of Leo Latu he looks like a classy player, fast from dummy half and, also, tackles hard. Wild is still producing the goods at Hudds, plus he scores tries. Nero, Gleeson and Bailey are strange signings IMO, I would like to think they are just adding a little depth to the squad, but knowing McRae he'll probably dump 1/2 of our younger players to accommodate them. Additionally we've signed Adam Neal, part way through last season I know, but he definitely improves the front row that started last season.



Our main problems in 2010 were lack of go forward and defence. Palea'asina will certainly improve the go forward and the likes of Anderson and Wild should help improve the defence.



Don't forget we've still got Cashmere, Sidlow, Broughton and Gibson who can all turn a game.



P.S. Thanks for the last two.

a successful salford team might just persuade the national press that are moving to manchester to improve their coverage of the game



the hard part for all teams recruiting 7-8 players is making them gel, its no coincidence that the teams that recruit the least tend to do better

crusaders were an exception last year but still didnt really click till halfway thru the season